Opinion: The compassionate life of Matthew Bisbee

The Orr, Minn., man died in a fire in February, along with the dogs he raised. A veteran, he’d said previously that the dogs were part of his healing process. He, and one of the dogs, were also that for me.

June 27, 2025 at 8:59PM
Matthew Bisbee with Winnie. (Provided by Caroline Giuffra)

Opinion editor’s note: Strib Voices publishes a mix of guest commentaries online and in print each day. To contribute, click here.

•••

On Sept. 24, 2023, I met a man who, in a short amount of time, left an impression that would stay with me forever. That day, I picked up my wire-haired dachshund, Winnie, from Matthew Bisbee, a man whose kindness and quiet strength resonated deeply with me.

I had recently undergone a full spinal fusion for scoliosis, and I was searching for a companion to help me through my recovery. It wasn’t long before I found Matthew, who, along with his wife, Paige, ran Black Beaver Creek Farm & Kennel, a place known for its wire-haired dachshunds. Matthew had traveled all the way from Minnesota to New York, driving countless hours just to meet me at LaGuardia Airport, outside Terminal C, next to a Starbucks. My mom and I were there to pick up Winnie, who at the time was still called Dainty. When Matthew arrived, he was accompanied by two dogs, Winnie and a much larger, scruffier dachshund. Without hesitation, he unzipped a small bag and handed me Dainty, now soon to become Winnie Louise. He explained that it would be too difficult for him to hold onto her any longer, his eyes softening as he passed her into my arms. “She’s yours now,” he said with a warm smile.

Along with Dainty, Matthew gave us a bag filled with the essentials: bowls, vitamins and a baby blanket that smelled of her parents, Boris and Penguin. He didn’t stop there. He showed me how to care for her ears; dachshunds, with their deep ear canals, require extra attention, and he offered advice on how to keep her healthy and happy. It was a thoughtful and thorough gesture, one that showed just how deeply he cared for the animals he raised.

As my mom and I spoke to Matt, I learned that Matthew wasn’t just a dog breeder — he was a military veteran, a father of seven and a mentor to many. He had served in the 82nd Airborne Division and earned a Bronze Star for heroism in Afghanistan. But what struck me most was how, despite his quiet strength, he was deeply moved by the dogs he cared for. When we spoke about his military service, about his life raising children and animals, Matthew grew unexpectedly emotional.

“The dogs saved me,” he said softly, looking down for a moment. “Every time I re-home one, it’s always hard to look back.”

In those words, I understood the depth of his connection to the animals he cared for. Matthew didn’t just see them as pets or companions; he saw them as part of his healing process, and as a way to help others heal. He had built a life around guiding people — whether through his military service, his role as a father, or the work he did with animals. His dogs weren’t just dogs to him — they were a source of comfort, of therapy and of connection. It’s funny how brief moments like that can shape how you see the world. That meeting with Matthew wasn’t supposed to be anything more than a simple exchange — a dog for a new companion. But it became something deeper. In those few moments, I was reminded of the power of kindness, of giving without hesitation, and of the ways in which we can heal and help one another.

After that day, I stayed in contact with both Matthew and his wife, Paige. I would send them photos and videos of Winnie, showing them how much she had become a part of my life and how happy she made me. They were always so kind and appreciative, and I could tell how much it meant to them to see their dogs thriving in their new homes. Through my close friend Hudson, I later learned of the heartbreaking tragedy that struck the Bisbee family. Hudson had become just as attached to Winnie as I had and would often check their kennel’s page to see which dogs were available, as he had planned to adopt one himself after graduation. It was through him that I heard the devastating news. Matthew’s life came to a tragic end on Feb. 6, 2025, when he perished in a fire on his farm along with 65 of the dogs he had so lovingly cared for. I like to believe that Matthew passed while trying to save those dogs, the creatures that had been such an important part of his life.

Matthew was a man whose legacy was quietly woven through the people and animals he cared for. I didn’t know him for long, but in that brief interaction, I felt the weight of his compassion and his deep commitment to helping others, whether human or animal. His life, though tragically cut short, leaves a mark on those of us who were fortunate enough to cross paths with him.

I will always be grateful for that day — thankful for Winnie, of course, but also for the opportunity to meet Matthew. I carry with me the memory of his quiet strength, his generosity, and the love he had for the dogs he raised. It’s not often that a brief encounter leaves such a lasting impact, but Matthew Bisbee’s life was one that, in just a few moments, showed me what it truly means to care for others.

Caroline Giuffra is an upcoming senior at New York University majoring in politics with a minor in broadcast journalism. She’s worked at Fox News for “Jesse Watters Primetime” and is a reporter for Campus Reform. A GoFundMe drive to support Paige Bisbee is here.

about the writer

about the writer

Caroline Giuffra