Minnesota Twins fall to Cleveland Guardians when Pablo López’s mistake starts an uprising

Pablo López pitched six scoreless innings, but his errant throw in the seventh allowed a run and set up Bo Naylor to hit a three-run homer.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
May 1, 2025 at 3:31AM
The Guardians' Jose Ramirez scores on Pablo López’s throwing error as Twins catcher Ryan Jeffers takes the throw in the seventh inning Wednesday. (Sue Ogrocki/The Associated Press)

CLEVELAND - Pablo López threw the baseball 90 times during Wednesday‘s game, most of them sensational. Then he threw it once more — and essentially lost the game.

Pitch No. 90 was a low-and-away changeup that Carlos Santana lunged at, producing a high chopper about 40 feet up the third-base line. López grabbed it, turned and threw it behind Santana’s back as he neared first base. Twins first baseman Ty France couldn’t reach it, and the ball bounced into foul territory in shallow right field, giving José Ramírez time to score the game’s first run from second base.

The play triggered a four-run inning, and doomed the Twins to their second consecutive loss, 4-2 at Progressive Field.

“There’s no excuse [for] throwing the ball the way I did. I could have just not thrown it or I could have made a better throw,” López said of his third throwing error of the season. “I was a little slow off the mound, probably thinking too much about my leg, and then just didn’t throw it well.”

Though Santana was given an infield hit, an on-target throw by López might have retired his former teammate. Instead, It was the eighth error charged to a Twins pitcher, more than any other team’s staff, and the third time this year that the error led directly to a Twins loss.

Brock Stewart relieved López after the error, and he issued a walk, then struck out Daniel Schneemann for what could have been the third out.

Instead, the next batter, Bo Naylor, hit a Stewart changeup six rows deep into the right-field seats, a three-run homer the Twins couldn’t match.

“Once they hit the homer, the game’s a totally different game. Until that homer, we’re still right there,” Twins manager Rocco Baldelli said. “Pablo threw some good pitches to Santana, but we didn’t get them. The two-strike pitch that gets called a ball, it looked like a good pitch.”

The Twins had issues with more than one pitch during that seventh-inning Guardians rally. Twins catcher Ryan Jeffers said home plate umpire Malachi Moore was not calling strikes low in the strike zone.

“I told the umpire. He’s known as one of the tighter [strike zones]. He missed more that inning than he should have,” Jeffers said. “It’s hard when the bottom of the zone is completely not there. It’s frustrating.”

It’s not just Wednesday, though, Jeffers said. “That seems to be a trend this year across the league,” he said. “The strike zone is the smallest it’s ever been.”

The loss wasn’t all López’s fault, of course, not given the Twins’ sudden loss of offense. After scoring 11 runs in Monday’s victory, the Twins have scored three runs in the 18 innings since, none of them coming via a Twins player batting in a teammate; they are 0-for-6 with runners in scoring position over the two days.

France reached the seats with a solo home run Tuesday, and Brooks Lee connected with the bases empty in the eighth inning Wednesday.

The other run came in the ninth inning off Cleveland closer Emmanuel Clase, who gave up two singles and then threw a wild pitch that enabled Trevor Larnach to score. But Clase struck out Kody Clemens to end the game for his 24th career save vs. the Twins, far and away his most against any team.

“We didn’t get much going offensively. In a 0-0 game or 1-0 game, you’ve got to find a way to punch it around, make something happen,” Baldelli said. “We’re trying to get back to where we were just a few days ago. We’re not far off from that. We have some guys that are still in a good head space, confidence-wise.”

The Twins had only six hits Wednesday, five singles and Lee’s homer, and only in the ninth inning did they have two runners on base at the same time. Luis L. Ortiz pitched 6⅓ scoreless innings for Cleveland.

With the game still scoreless, Byron Buxton beat out an infield hit with two outs in the sixth inning, then stole his 100th career base. Naylor’s throw bounced into center field, allowing Buxton to advance to third base, but Carlos Correa took a third strike to end the Twins’ “threat.”

about the writer

about the writer

Phil Miller

Reporter

Phil Miller has covered the Twins for the Minnesota Star Tribune since 2013. Previously, he covered the University of Minnesota football team, and from 2007-09, he covered the Twins for the Pioneer Press.

See Moreicon

More from Twins

card image

Righthander Pablo López pitched six scoreless innings, but his errant throw in the seventh allowed a run and set up Bo Naylor to hit a three-run homer.