Maple syrup lends a sweet touch to cocktails

Tap into the springtime ingredient when making drinks at home, from Old Fashioneds to whiskey sours.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
March 5, 2025 at 5:00PM
Maple Old Fashioned from Tattersall Distilling. (Melissa Hesse/The Restaurant Project)

Maple syrup is a natural for pancakes and baking, and it has shown its prowess in savory dishes. But the springtime ingredient is equally at home in cocktails, too.

Bentley Gilman, head distiller of Tattersall Distilling in River Falls, Wis., created these four cocktails using its Birkie WI-SKI, which was created “in the spirit of” the American Birkebeiner, aging rye whiskey in used maple syrup barrels. While the cocktails — including one NA — were highlighted at the distillery’s Maplefest in February, they are top of mind now as we start thinking about syrup season — and spring.

Follow these recipes to the letter or use them as a road map to create your own. They all call for Tattersall’s Birkie WI-SKI, but feel free to use the rye whiskey (preferably aged in maple barrels) of your choice.

Maple Old Fashioned

Makes 1.

  • 2 oz. (4 tbsp.) Birkie WI-SKI
    • ¾ oz. (1 ½ tbsp.) maple syrup
      • 4 dash Aromatic bitters
        • Orange peel

          Directions

          Stir whiskey and syrup with ice until well chilled. Strain into rocks glass with fresh ice or one large ice cube. Add a dash or five of bitters and garnish with the rip of orange peel.

          Maple Whiskey Sour from Tattersall Distillery. (Melissa Hesse/The Restaurant Project)

          Maple Whiskey Sour

          Makes 1.

          Note: The egg white or aquafaba is optional, but really worth it. Aquafaba is the liquid from a can of unsalted chickpeas.

          • 2 oz. (4 tbsp.) Birkie WI-SKI
            • ¾ oz. (1 ½ tbsp.) maple syrup
              • ¾ oz. (1 ½ tbsp.) lemon Juice
                • 1 egg white or 3 tsp. aquafaba (see Note)

                  Directions

                  Combine the whiskey, syrup, lemon juice and egg white in a shaker with ice and shake vigorously. Strain into a rocks glass with fresh ice.

                  Maple Whiskey Hot Toddy

                  Makes 1.

                  • 1 ½ oz. (3 tbsp.) Birkie WI-SKI
                    • ½ oz. (1 tbsp.) maple syrup
                      • ½ oz. (1 tbsp.) lemon juice
                        • 4 oz. (½ c.) just-boiled water
                          • Lemon wheel, for optional garnish
                            • Cinnamon stick, for optional garnish

                              Directions

                              In a large mug, stir together the whiskey, maple syrup and lemon juice. Top with the hot water. Garnish with lemon wheel or a cinnamon stick before serving.

                              NA Maple Collins

                              Makes 1.

                              • 1 oz. (2 tbsp.) maple syrup
                                • ½ oz. (1 tbsp.) lemon juice
                                  • Soda water
                                    • 1 tsp. fruit juice of choice, optional
                                      • Lemon wedge, for garnish

                                        Directions

                                        Fill a Collins glass with ice. Pour in maple syrup and lemon juice and top with soda water. Add fruit juice, if using. Stir, garnish with lemon wedge and enjoy.

                                        about the writer

                                        about the writer

                                        Star Tribune staff

                                        See More

                                        More from Eat & Drink

                                        card image

                                        Tap into the springtime ingredient when making drinks at home, from Old Fashioneds to whiskey sours.

                                        card image
                                        card image